logo

Ideal House APP

Your Go-To Interior Design Hub
HomeHome
BoardBoard
ExploreExplore
Logo
N
NOLA.com

The real stories behind those TV home makeover shows: New design podcast dishes on why they're harmful

The perception of home makeover shows on television, which often depict rapid transformations within a single episode, is critiqued by Mark Brunetz, Emmy Award-winning co-host of the former Style Network series “Clean House.” Brunetz, who spent nine years on the show, reveals that these productions require extensive resources, including a crew of 100 people and a week of work for each home. He points out a significant disconnect between the glamorized on-screen portrayals and the reality of the design process, which is far more complex and nuanced than what is typically shown. Motivated by this insight, Brunetz launched a podcast titled "Scandalabra: The Ugly Truth Behind Beautiful Spaces," available on various podcast platforms. This podcast aims to delve deeper into the design industry, moving beyond superficial aesthetics and the emotional reveals commonly featured on TV. Since its launch in July, the podcast has featured 24 candid interviews with design insiders, with more episodes planned. These discussions have brought to light critical perspectives on the home improvement genre. One recurring theme in the podcast, articulated by designer Jaime Rummerfield, is that while home makeover shows have raised awareness about home improvement, they have also inadvertently cheapened the fields of design and architecture. Rummerfield draws a parallel between "fast design" and "fast fashion," where products are made to look appealing for a brief moment but lack durability and substance. This trend pushes poorly made furniture and quick fixes, prioritizing immediate visual impact over lasting quality and thoughtful design. Another criticism highlighted is the common practice of showing sledgehammer demolitions in every episode. While visually engaging for television, such structural changes are often unnecessary or inappropriate for many homes, demonstrating a focus on dramatic effect rather than practical design solutions. Brunetz's interviews frequently reveal that many people tend to copy design trends, which can result in homes that lack personal authenticity. Guests on the podcast emphasize that individuals often feel pressured to adhere to a single design style, influenced by quizzes or prevailing trends. However, the true objective of design, as argued by these experts, is to create a space that genuinely reflects the homeowner's personality and lifestyle, rather than a generic or trendy aesthetic. Angelo Surmelis, a guest on an episode titled “The Dangers of Idolizing TV Designers,” advises against mimicking the styles of TV design experts or blindly following trends. He asserts that companies often manufacture trends primarily to boost product sales, and that true design expertise for one's personal space comes from within. The article suggests that embracing personal preferences and individual taste is more crucial than following a prescribed "color of the year" or an "expert's" recommendation, requiring self-reflection to determine one's authentic style. Renowned architect Dean Larkin, known for his work on high-value properties, advocates for ignoring "isms" in design. He argues that adhering strictly to movements like midcentury modernism or traditionalism limits the opportunity to develop a unique personal aesthetic. Larkin stresses that a home should function as a personal sanctuary, reflecting the occupants and their family. He also cautions against rushing the design process, contrasting it with the expedited timelines seen on TV shows. Successful rooms, he contends, evolve over time. Larkin also challenges the concept of "timeless design," asserting that great design inherently connects people, space, and the specific era they inhabit, and thus is always subject to change. Regarding the impact of the pandemic on home design, Brunetz notes that it merely amplified existing issues. The increased time spent at home caused many to scrutinize their living environments more closely, revealing dissatisfactions with spaces that did not genuinely reflect them. Those who thrived at home during this period were often those whose living spaces resonated with their personal identities. To help individuals discover their personal style, Brunetz employs an interview technique where he asks about their hobbies, travel preferences, favorite clothing, or even what piece of furniture they would be, detailing its characteristics. This method helps people articulate their aesthetic inclinations, underscoring that everyone possesses a distinct style. #HomeMakeoverShows #DesignPodcast #InteriorDesignCritique #AuthenticDesign #DesignTrends #HomeDecoration #DesignIndustryInsights #ScandalabraPodcast #MarkBrunetz #HomeMakeoverShows #DesignPodcast #InteriorDesignCritique #AuthenticDesign #DesignTrends #HomeDecoration #DesignIndustryInsights #ScandalabraPodcast #MarkBrunetz
No comments yet
13 Worst ‘Trading Spaces’ Designs, From the Sob-Inducing Fireplace to Straw-Covered Walls (Photos)
13 Worst ‘Trading Spaces’ Designs, From the Sob-Inducing Fireplace to Straw-Covered Walls (Photos)
Interior Design Masters and 7 more shows to watch for homes inspiration
Interior Design Masters and 7 more shows to watch for homes inspiration
The 13 Biggest "Scams" in Home Design Today, According to Designers
The 13 Biggest "Scams" in Home Design Today, According to Designers
The original 'Trading Spaces' designers, ranked
The original 'Trading Spaces' designers, ranked
The Most Controversial Design Choices We've Seen On HGTV's Fixer Upper
The Most Controversial Design Choices We've Seen On HGTV's Fixer Upper
From Friends to Frasier: 13 Famous TV Shows Rendered in Plan
From Friends to Frasier: 13 Famous TV Shows Rendered in Plan
You Should Probably Stop Watching Home Improvement Shows
You Should Probably Stop Watching Home Improvement Shows
Married To Real Estate: 10 Best Kitchen Renovations According To Fans
Married To Real Estate: 10 Best Kitchen Renovations According To Fans
Move That Bus! — See the Original 'Extreme Makeover: Home Edition' Cast Today
Move That Bus! — See the Original 'Extreme Makeover: Home Edition' Cast Today
The 100 Best Reality Shows About Interior Designers, Ranked
The 100 Best Reality Shows About Interior Designers, Ranked
"Frankly, It's Tacky": People Are Revealing Common Interior Design Trends They Can't Stand
"Frankly, It's Tacky": People Are Revealing Common Interior Design Trends They Can't Stand
Money for Nothing: meet the team of presenters and designers
Money for Nothing: meet the team of presenters and designers
'Extreme Makeover: Home Edition' Was Less Wholesome and Way More Controversial Than You Remember
'Extreme Makeover: Home Edition' Was Less Wholesome and Way More Controversial Than You Remember
See The Floor Plans From Your Favorite TV Homes
See The Floor Plans From Your Favorite TV Homes
Behind the scenes of a historic kitchen remodel with Design Collective STL
Behind the scenes of a historic kitchen remodel with Design Collective STL
The McGee Home Refresh
The McGee Home Refresh
"It's Like I'm On An HGTV Acid Trip": People Are Denouncing The Worst Home Design Features
"It's Like I'm On An HGTV Acid Trip": People Are Denouncing The Worst Home Design Features
"Frankly, It's Tacky": People Are Revealing Common Home And Kitchen Design Trends They Can't Stand
"Frankly, It's Tacky": People Are Revealing Common Home And Kitchen Design Trends They Can't Stand
The Interior Designers Making Podcast Studios Feel Just Like Home
The Interior Designers Making Podcast Studios Feel Just Like Home
The Great Interior Design Challenge is the splendid makeover that the interior design competition needed
The Great Interior Design Challenge is the splendid makeover that the interior design competition needed