
1/4
"Relax, it's not a toilet"
This article presents a weekly comments update from Dezeen, highlighting reader discussions on four diverse design and architecture topics. The first discussion centers on the placement of a toilet in Le Corbusier's Paris apartment within the Immeuble Molitor, which recently reopened to the public. Readers express varying degrees of discomfort and confusion regarding the toilet's open visibility within the living space, with some questioning the practicality and social implications of such a design. One reader attributes the concept to ancient Greek and Roman public baths, while another attempts to clarify that the fixture in question is a bidet, leading to further debate about its intended use and location relative to a toilet.
The second topic covers the controversy surrounding Roger Scruton's appointment as chair of the UK government's Building Better, Building Beautiful commission. Readers are divided on whether he should be removed from his post due to controversial statements he made in past lectures. Some readers, like Duckusucker, satirically suggest he would be a good candidate for US presidency, while others, such as James, argue that his comments are being taken out of context. Ray Thomson expresses disapproval of the calls for Scruton's dismissal, suggesting his appointment was legitimate, and Jb frames the situation as an attempt to hobble an opponent.
The third discussion focuses on OMA's recently completed housing development in Stockholm, specifically the 'Innovationen Tower' of the Norra Tornen project. Readers largely express disappointment with the building's aesthetic, citing a perceived lack of humanism. Jay C. White Cloud critiques the architecture as not enduring and reflective of human ego and indifference to nature. Pladde questions how a project aiming for humanism could result in a brutalist tower, and CriticAI compares it unfavorably to older brutalist examples like the Barbican towers. Mr J succinctly states he wouldn't want to live in or even look at it, though the article implies not all feedback was negative.
Finally, the article highlights reader comments on Gianni Botsford Architects' 'House in a Garden' in west London, which features a funnel-shaped copper roof and a copper kitchen. Commenters acknowledge the opulence and beauty of the design but debate its practicality. Eric praises the beautiful results despite the needless extravagance. Giles Heather specifically notes the 'deeply impractical copper kitchen,' a sentiment echoed by Jo P, who calls it both impractical and ugly. HeywoodFloyd strongly criticizes the design as 'completely over designed' and finds the copper kitchen cabinet fronts 'impractical to the point of being offensive.' The article concludes by inviting further discussion on these topics, emphasizing the varied opinions among readers regarding contemporary architectural and design choices.
#Architecture #InteriorDesign #LeCorbusier #ParisApartment #DesignDebate #BuildingBetterBuildingBeautiful #RogerScruton #OMAStockholm #CopperKitchen #Architecture #InteriorDesign #LeCorbusier #ParisApartment #DesignDebate #BuildingBetterBuildingBeautiful #RogerScruton #OMAStockholm #CopperKitchen
0 comment in total
No comments yetYou may also like


































