
1/7
GE Smart Lighting review: ZigBee or Z-Wave? In-wall or plug-in?
Jasco Products manufactures a range of in-wall and plug-in lighting controls under the GE brand, utilizing both Z-Wave and ZigBee platforms. These smart lighting solutions can be integrated with voice assistants like Alexa or Google Assistant, though Z-Wave products necessitate a third-party hub for connectivity. ZigBee products also typically require a third-party hub, with the exception of the Amazon Echo Plus, which has a built-in ZigBee controller. Apple HomeKit compatibility is not offered by these specific GE devices.
Testing involved the GE In-Wall ZigBee Smart Dimmer (model 45857GE), the GE In-Wall Z-Wave Smart Dimmer (model 14294), and the GE ZigBee Plug-in Smart Dimmer (model 45852GE), all integrated with a Samsung SmartThings Hub, which supports both communication protocols.
The GE In-Wall ZigBee Smart Dimmer, designed to replace standard light switches, requires a neutral wire in the junction box and, for multi-pole configurations, GE add-on switches. Installation is complicated by poorly written and confusing instructions, with oversized diagrams for old switches and tiny, hard-to-read diagrams for the new device. Despite these challenges, the physical installation can be completed with patience. The dimmer features a rocker-like appearance but operates with taps: a tap on the top turns the light on, and a tap on the bottom turns it off. Pressing and holding allows for dimming or brightening, compatible with various dimmable bulb types. A small LED indicates the switch's location in the dark, though it cannot be turned off independently. Pairing with the SmartThings hub proved difficult, requiring multiple device resets and calls to tech support before successful integration. Once paired, the dimmer functioned like other SmartThings devices, supporting basic automation and offering real-time energy monitoring within the app. However, issues with slow dimming action and flicker with older LED bulbs were noted.
The GE In-Wall Z-Wave Plus Smart Dimmer is nearly identical in design and installation requirements to its ZigBee counterpart, including the need for a neutral wire and add-on switches for multi-pole setups. Its manual is similarly disorganized and confusing. Unlike the ZigBee model, this version paired easily with the SmartThings hub, as it does not require a special pairing mode. Operationally, it mirrors the ZigBee dimmer, though it lacks an energy-monitoring feature. Notably, the Z-Wave dimmer has a lower list price ($44.99) compared to the ZigBee model ($54.99). For users with an Echo Plus, the ZigBee model might be considered despite setup issues, but for those with a Z-Wave compatible hub, the Z-Wave dimmer is presented as the superior choice.
The GE ZigBee Plug-in Smart Dimmer is designed for impermanent light sources with dimmable bulbs and requires grounded, three-prong receptacles. It includes an always-on three-prong pass-through, while the controlled outlet accepts two-pronged plugs. This plug-in dimmer is described as large, measuring 4 inches wide by 2.5 inches high by 1.5 inches deep, but is designed not to obstruct the second outlet in a two-gang receptacle. A recessed button on the front controls the attached lamp, with a single press for on/off and holding for dimming/brightening, though the dimming action is slow and the button is difficult to manipulate. Unlike the in-wall ZigBee dimmer, this plug-in version paired immediately with the SmartThings app, offering comprehensive lighting controls, automation, and real-time energy consumption reporting. It handles up to a 300-watt incandescent load or 100-watt dimmable CFL/LED bulbs, with a maximum load of 15 amps or 1,800 watts across both outlets. Despite its size, it is deemed a competent choice for a dimmable smart plug, and its Z-Wave equivalent is presumed to offer similar capabilities.
#GESmartLighting #ZigBee #ZWave #SmartHome #HomeAutomation #SmartDimmer #LightingControl #SmartThings #ProductReview #GESmartLighting #ZigBee #ZWave #SmartHome #HomeAutomation #SmartDimmer #LightingControl #SmartThings #ProductReview
0 comment in total
No comments yetYou may also like






























































