
1/23
This Shelter Island Victorian’s Porch Is Such a Vibe That It’s Been Mistaken for a Restaurant
Annie Sullivan Cobb discovered Shelter Island, New York, in her early 20s and immediately felt a connection to its lush environment and historic Heights neighborhood. This sentiment was shared by her British husband, Oliver. Over the years, during their visits, they consistently admired a particular Victorian house, especially its sprawling hydrangeas visible from the side garden. This circa-1880 property, which Annie described as enchanted, eventually came on the market, and the couple purchased it in 2012, just before their first daughter's birthday. They continue to reside in Brooklyn full-time.
Initially, they rented out the Shelter Island house due to the demands of raising two young children in Brooklyn. Building a local community also took time, a process aided by their children's summer camps on the island. A decade after their purchase, the couple embarked on an extensive renovation. This included installing central air-conditioning, adding a new patio, and constructing a mudroom and breakfast nook adjacent to the galley kitchen. Annie, who had recently co-founded an interior design business, Sullivan Matthews, with Saara Matthews, oversaw the design. She aimed to maintain the home's original gingerbread Victorian details, such as the intricate gable trim and existing floors, while incorporating modern elements and wallpaper in certain areas.
The design approach for the house leaned towards an English country aesthetic, influenced by a friend's London home and featuring products from British brands. They integrated classic Shaker cabinetry and unlacquered brass accessories from DeVol. The kitchen floors were painted with Farrow & Ball’s Sardine, a blue hue, color-matched by Kirby’s Paints, a company known for durable marine-grade finishes. The renovation included a playful design decision: a closet between the kitchen and dining room was transformed into a secret bar. This idea originated from a designer friend, Starrett Hoyt Ringbom, during a visit. Annie initially painted the nook blue-green but ultimately chose Farrow & Ball’s Sulking Room Pink, complete with a wine fridge/ice maker and a bow handle from Beata Heuman.
Oliver, Annie's husband, took charge of transforming a nearby closet into his own domain, painting it in Farrow & Ball’s Churlish Green. This closet now houses his record collection and a vintage turntable set into a soapstone counter. His passion for hi-fi extends to the living room, where 1960s KLH Model 6 speakers enhance the atmosphere for social gatherings. During the quieter winter months, the family retreats to the island, enjoying stews, fires, and games indoors, now made more comfortable with central air.
Addressing the lack of built-in storage typical of 1880s homes, Annie found creative solutions. She repurposed an antique decorative trunk from Cape Cod for linens and customized a basic IKEA headboard by wrapping it in foam and a Moroccan wedding blanket. When their bedside tables were upgraded to sleek Componibili storage units, the old Victorian tables were moved to the porch to serve as pedestals for potted ferns. The family's plant collection grew significantly during COVID-19, becoming a noticeable feature of the home. The dining table was relocated to the new garden patio for privacy, a response to passersby who often mistook their porch-side meals for a restaurant. Despite the public nature of their home, the Sullivans embrace the community feel, often inviting neighbors and their children inside, fostering an old-fashioned sense of hospitality.
#HomeTour #VictorianHome #ShelterIsland #InteriorDesign #Renovation #EnglishCountryStyle #DesignInspiration #DIY #FamilyHome #HomeTour #VictorianHome #ShelterIsland #InteriorDesign #Renovation #EnglishCountryStyle #DesignInspiration #DIY #FamilyHome
0 comment in total
No comments yetYou may also like

































































