
1/5
Rogue builders quoted over £15k for a repair job that cost £185 to fix - my lessons learnt
The author recounts a personal experience with a roof repair that highlighted significant discrepancies in builder quotes and the importance of independent assessment. The issue began when a surveyor identified a split purlin and sagging rafters in the roof of the author's 200-year-old mid-terrace house. Initially, a structural engineer suggested the repair would be relatively inexpensive, attributing the purlin failure to the replacement of original slate tiles with heavier concrete ones. However, prospective buyers subsequently demanded a full roof replacement cost be deducted from the sale price, leading to the collapse of the sale.
Following a cancer diagnosis and successful treatment, the author revisited the roof repair. Upon advertising the job on builder-finding websites, a wide range of quotes were received. While one builder offered to replace the purlin for approximately £2,000, other tradesmen insisted the entire roof structure was unsafe and required complete replacement, with quotes reaching up to £15,000, excluding VAT. Skeptical of these high estimates, the author opted for a second opinion from an independent structural engineer, costing £420.
This engineer's report revealed that the house's original builders had used one purlin that was an inch thinner than the others, leading to its eventual failure. Crucially, the report confirmed that the rest of the roof was structurally sound, contradicting the expensive assessments provided by some builders. Armed with this information, the author sought a new roofer, receiving a recommendation for 'Kev the builder.'
'Kev' confirmed that a full roof replacement was unnecessary, as there were no signs of water ingress and the roof had many decades of life left. He efficiently replaced the purlin in a single morning, and the total cost for materials and labor was only £185. The author, pleased with the outcome, paid £250. This experience underscored two key lessons: the value of investing in an independent structural engineer's report to avoid exorbitant repair costs, and the importance of seeking multiple quotes and recommendations from trusted sources when hiring tradespeople.
#PropertyRepair #HomeRenovation #RogueBuilders #StructuralEngineer #RoofRepair #ConsumerAdvice #BuilderQuotes #FinancialPrudence #PropertyRepair #HomeRenovation #RogueBuilders #StructuralEngineer #RoofRepair #ConsumerAdvice #BuilderQuotes #FinancialPrudence
Aún no hay comentarios











