logo

Ideal House APP

Your Go-To Interior Design Hub
HomeHome
BoardBoard
ExploreExplore
Logo
1/3

HGTV's Erin Napier Warns Against This Countertop Type In Old Homes

The article discusses advice from HGTV's Erin Napier regarding countertop selection for kitchen renovations in historic homes, drawing insights from an episode of "Home Town" titled "New-Stalgic Restoration." In this episode, Erin and Ben Napier undertake the renovation of a Victorian home in Laurel, Mississippi, aiming to preserve its historical integrity while modernizing its functionality. Erin Napier specifically advises against using white countertops in such projects, stating that they feel "out of synchronicity" with a house from 1900. Instead, for the Victorian home's kitchen, she opted for a granite countertop featuring swirls of brown and cream, which was chosen to complement greige-toned Shaker cabinetry and a cream-colored subway tile backsplash. This selection reflects a strategy of harmonizing modern elements with the existing historical aesthetic. The article further explores alternative countertop ideas suitable for historic homes, acknowledging that early 20th-century kitchens primarily featured functional furniture rather than built-in cabinetry or aesthetically driven countertops. It suggests drawing inspiration from Victorian home pantries, which often incorporated wood, metal, or marble counters. While marble remains a popular choice today, the article highlights quartz countertops as a more durable alternative that can mimic the look of marble. Another recommendation for a darker, matte finish is soapstone, noted for its resilience compared to marble. Honed granite is also presented as an option that can provide an aged, matte appearance fitting for older homes. Beyond countertops, the article delves into other modern elements that can be integrated into a historic kitchen without compromising its character. Erin Napier's approach in the "New-Stalgic Restoration" emphasizes restoring and returning the home to its perceived original state. This involves selecting contemporary materials for cabinets, counters, and fixtures that blend seamlessly with the home's age. Examples include installing a farmhouse sink for a nostalgic touch, potentially in materials like copper to echo Victorian pantry metals. Painted Shaker cabinets are also noted as a suitable complement for modernized historic kitchens. The article also mentions the possibility of integrating appliances, such as refrigerators, behind cabinetry for a more cohesive look, provided it aligns with the renovation budget. Additionally, wooden flooring is highlighted as an appropriate choice for period kitchens, with the Napiers uncovering original pine floors in their project as a pleasant, albeit often requiring refinishing, discovery. The overall message conveyed is that while bringing a historic home into the 21st century demands significant effort, the endeavor can be rewarding, particularly when careful consideration is given to maintaining an authentic feel, such as by avoiding stark white countertops. #ErinNapier #HGTV #HomeRenovation #HistoricHomes #KitchenRemodel #CountertopSelection #InteriorDesign #HomeTown #VictorianHome #ErinNapier #HGTV #HomeRenovation #HistoricHomes #KitchenRemodel #CountertopSelection #InteriorDesign #HomeTown #VictorianHome
No comments yet
This Countertop Style Was Just Deemed “Horrifying” (Again)
This Countertop Style Was Just Deemed “Horrifying” (Again)
This Once-Taboo Kitchen Flooring Is Climbing the Ranks
This Once-Taboo Kitchen Flooring Is Climbing the Ranks
Sorry, Marble: Home Buyers Still Prefer This Kitchen Countertop Material
Sorry, Marble: Home Buyers Still Prefer This Kitchen Countertop Material
The Kitchen Countertop Material Designers Say You Should Avoid
The Kitchen Countertop Material Designers Say You Should Avoid
This Once-Popular Kitchen Trend Is Actually a Huge Pain—Here’s One Designer’s Solution
This Once-Popular Kitchen Trend Is Actually a Huge Pain—Here’s One Designer’s Solution
Outdated Trends That HGTV's Property Brothers Swear Are Ruining Your Home's Vibe
Outdated Trends That HGTV's Property Brothers Swear Are Ruining Your Home's Vibe
The Once-Popular Kitchen Counter Style Real Estate Pros Say Is Outdated
The Once-Popular Kitchen Counter Style Real Estate Pros Say Is Outdated
12 Once-Popular Kitchen Trends That Won't Be Coming Back Anytime Soon
12 Once-Popular Kitchen Trends That Won't Be Coming Back Anytime Soon
Designers reveal the outdated countertop materials we should all be avoiding in 2024
Designers reveal the outdated countertop materials we should all be avoiding in 2024
The Once-Popular Kitchen Counter Style Real Estate Pros Say Is Outdated
The Once-Popular Kitchen Counter Style Real Estate Pros Say Is Outdated
The Countertop Material That We Loved 25 Years Ago Is Coming Back
The Countertop Material That We Loved 25 Years Ago Is Coming Back
Cherry Cabinets and Granite Counters Usually Scream ’90s—Not in This Pittsburgh Kitchen
Cherry Cabinets and Granite Counters Usually Scream ’90s—Not in This Pittsburgh Kitchen
HGTV's Hilary Farr Doesn't Want Homeowners To Focus On This 'Distracting' Kitchen Feature
HGTV's Hilary Farr Doesn't Want Homeowners To Focus On This 'Distracting' Kitchen Feature
The #1 Home Trend You Should Avoid, According to Designers
The #1 Home Trend You Should Avoid, According to Designers
After More Than 500 Home Makeovers, the Property Brothers Warn Against This Feature They "Hate, Hate, Hate"
After More Than 500 Home Makeovers, the Property Brothers Warn Against This Feature They "Hate, Hate, Hate"
From the Utensil Rack to the Tub, All That’s New in This Home Is Meant to Look Old
From the Utensil Rack to the Tub, All That’s New in This Home Is Meant to Look Old
"Frankly, It's Tacky": People Are Revealing Common Home And Kitchen Design Trends They Can't Stand
"Frankly, It's Tacky": People Are Revealing Common Home And Kitchen Design Trends They Can't Stand
4 Kitchen Countertop Materials About to Make a Comeback
4 Kitchen Countertop Materials About to Make a Comeback
"It's Like I'm On An HGTV Acid Trip": People Are Denouncing The Worst Home Design Features
"It's Like I'm On An HGTV Acid Trip": People Are Denouncing The Worst Home Design Features
Designers Say in 2025, You Should Not Have This in Your Kitchen or Bathroom
Designers Say in 2025, You Should Not Have This in Your Kitchen or Bathroom