
Erin Napier Defends Controversial Design Decision From 'Home Town Takeover'
In the third season of HGTV's 'Home Town Takeover,' designers Ben and Erin Napier undertook a significant home renovation in Sebring, Florida, focusing on updating a local teacher's residence. The project encompassed a complete overhaul, ranging from the front porch and dining room to the kitchen, with the goal of refreshing the home's aesthetic while preserving its historical integrity. The Napiers showcased their design choices, which included a 'dreamboat' kitchen, intending to create a modern yet respectful update.
However, one particular design element, the placement of the range directly in front of a window, sparked a notable debate among viewers. Erin Napier, who expressed her enthusiasm for this unconventional choice, shared photos of the renovation on her Instagram account, leading to immediate public commentary. Some viewers voiced concerns about practicality, citing issues such as potential grease buildup on the window, the difficulty of cleaning it by reaching over the stove, and the desire to have a clear view outside while washing dishes. These comments reflected a preference for traditional kitchen layouts where ranges are typically positioned against a solid wall or with a dedicated backsplash.
Conversely, other viewers supported the design, highlighting advantages such as the convenience of opening a window directly behind the stove to ventilate smoke or strong odors from cooking. Erin Napier herself joined the discussion to defend her decision, asserting that cleaning a glass window in this position is no different from, and potentially easier than, cleaning a glossy tiled backsplash, particularly because it lacks grout. She further clarified that in a climate like Florida's, windows are typically closed and air conditioning is used, mitigating concerns about insects entering. She also pointed out the presence of a vent above the range, indicating that proper ventilation was considered in the design.
Ben Napier also weighed in, stating that placing a range in front of a window is a common practice and not a novel concept introduced by their team. He emphasized that the primary view from the sink, which overlooks Lake Jackson, offers a superior aesthetic experience compared to the view from the range. He concluded his defense by affirming that the homeowner had approved and was pleased with the designs prior to the commencement of the renovation, underscoring that client satisfaction was the ultimate measure of success for the project.
#HomeTownTakeover #ErinNapier #BenNapier #HGTV #HomeRenovation #KitchenDesign #InteriorDesign #DesignControversy #FloridaHome #HomeTownTakeover #ErinNapier #BenNapier #HGTV #HomeRenovation #KitchenDesign #InteriorDesign #DesignControversy #FloridaHome
0 comment in total
No comments yetYou may also like















