logo

Ideal House APP

Your Go-To Interior Design Hub
HomeHome
BoardBoard
ExploreExplore
Logo

9 Editor-Tested Pillows That Made Us Ditch Our Old Ones for Good

Selecting the ideal pillow can be a complex task given the wide array of fill materials available, from soft down alternatives to firm memory foam. The Spruce team undertook extensive testing, evaluating over 118 pillows to identify the best options for various preferences and sleep positions. This comprehensive review highlights nine top-performing pillows, emphasizing factors such as comfort, support, durability, and unique features. The testing methodology involved multiple team members using and comparing pillows in their own homes over several weeks. Each pillow was assessed for its material and construction, comfort and support across different sleeping positions (side, back, stomach), ability to maintain head, neck, and back alignment, and resistance to wear and tear like lumps, flattening, and shrinkage. The team also considered the long-term durability of each pillow, noting how loftiness changed over time and after washing. The Casper Original Pillow was named the "Best Overall" due to its comfortable "pillow-in-a-pillow" design, which provides both fluffiness and firm support, making it suitable for side and back sleepers. Testers praised its comfort, with one noting an audible sigh of relief upon use, and its sustained quality after six months of consistent use. However, its high loft might not be ideal for stomach sleepers, and its machine washability still requires further long-term assessment. For those seeking value, the Serta Down Essence Medium Bed Pillow stood out as the "Best Value." This down-alternative option offers a soft, squishy feel and is fully machine-washable. While it has a lower loft, it provides ample support for all sleep positions. A minor drawback is its tendency to trap heat, which might be a consideration for hot sleepers. The Coop Sleep Goods Original Pillow earned the title of "Best Foam" due to its adjustable fill of shredded memory foam and microfiber. This allows users to customize the loft and firmness, accommodating back, side, and stomach sleepers. Its durable foam retains shape well, though it has an initial off-gassing period that dissipates within a few days. The Fluff Co Down Feather Pillow was recognized as the "Best Down" pillow. Despite down's reputation for deflating, this pillow maintained its loft due to its unique inner feather core and outer down layer, offering a firm yet comfortable experience. It also comes with a pillow protector, which is crucial as the pillow itself is not washable. "Best Down Alternative" went to the Slumber Cloud Core Down Alternative Pillow, celebrated for its surprisingly plush yet thin design and machine washability, making it a durable and convenient choice. While its long-term washability is still under evaluation, initial tests showed no signs of wear. The Leesa Latex Pillow, dubbed "Best Latex," impressed with its bouncy, resilient feel and excellent breathability, which helps regulate temperature. While supportive for back sleepers, its lower height might not be sufficient for side sleepers. The Company Store Down Alternative Chamber Pillow was identified as the "Best for Back Sleepers," offering a balanced blend of firm structure and soft fluffiness, suitable even for some side sleepers due to its unique two-chamber design. The Theradown by Therapedic Natural Feather & Down Pillow was chosen as "Best for Side Sleepers" because of its ability to keep the neck and spine aligned, thanks to its thicker, supportive polyester and down-feather blend, though its outer fabric can be noisy. Lastly, The Silk & Snow Pillow was recommended as the "Best for Stomach Sleepers" due to its adjustable shredded memory foam, allowing stomach sleepers to achieve their desired softness and thickness, despite the slight difficulty in reinserting the inner pillow after adjustment. Overall, the choice of pillow ultimately depends on individual preferences for firmness, loft, and sleeping position. The review underscores the importance of considering fill material, sleep position, adjustable features, and cooling properties when selecting a pillow for optimal comfort and support. #PillowReview #BeddingEssentials #SleepComfort #HomeDecor #SleepingPositions #AdjustablePillows #CoolingPillows #MemoryFoam #DownAlternative #PillowReview #BeddingEssentials #SleepComfort #HomeDecor #SleepingPositions #AdjustablePillows #CoolingPillows #MemoryFoam #DownAlternative
No comments yet
I spent hundreds of hours testing the best pillows — these are my top picks
I spent hundreds of hours testing the best pillows — these are my top picks
Ditch Overpriced Designer Throw Blankets & Pillows And Opt For These 10 Smarter Alternatives
Ditch Overpriced Designer Throw Blankets & Pillows And Opt For These 10 Smarter Alternatives
The 9 Very Best Pillows for Side Sleepers
The 9 Very Best Pillows for Side Sleepers
8 Bath Pillows We Tested for Ultimate Relaxation
8 Bath Pillows We Tested for Ultimate Relaxation
Yes, We Swapped Out Our Own Beds for These 8 Designs—Here's What We Think
Yes, We Swapped Out Our Own Beds for These 8 Designs—Here's What We Think
Best pillows for every kind of sleeper in 2025, tried and tested
Best pillows for every kind of sleeper in 2025, tried and tested
The 7 Best Pillowcases That We Tested, Including Silk, Sateen, and Cotton
The 7 Best Pillowcases That We Tested, Including Silk, Sateen, and Cotton
The 8 Very Best Pillows for Back Sleepers
The 8 Very Best Pillows for Back Sleepers
We Tested Dozens of Memory Foam Pillows. These Are the Best.
We Tested Dozens of Memory Foam Pillows. These Are the Best.
As a certified sleep coach who tested 17 body pillows, I can say they're the most underrated sleep upgrade
As a certified sleep coach who tested 17 body pillows, I can say they're the most underrated sleep upgrade
These Pillows for Sitting up in Bed Will 100% Change Your Life
These Pillows for Sitting up in Bed Will 100% Change Your Life
The 7 Very Best Down Pillows
The 7 Very Best Down Pillows
7 Pillowcases That Are So Good, We'd Buy Them Separate From Their Matching Sheets
7 Pillowcases That Are So Good, We'd Buy Them Separate From Their Matching Sheets
Best pillows in 2025 for every kind of sleeper, tried and tested
Best pillows in 2025 for every kind of sleeper, tried and tested
The 7 Best Down-Alternative Pillows
The 7 Best Down-Alternative Pillows
The Most Comfortable Reading Pillows of 2025, Vetted By Our Editors
The Most Comfortable Reading Pillows of 2025, Vetted By Our Editors
Fall’s Coziest Bedding Swaps Are Here—Shop 27 Editors' Picks for a Dreamy Upgrade
Fall’s Coziest Bedding Swaps Are Here—Shop 27 Editors' Picks for a Dreamy Upgrade
The 8 Best Backrest Pillows to Buy Right Now
The 8 Best Backrest Pillows to Buy Right Now
The 11 Best Sleeper Chairs You’ll Prefer to Your Own Damn Bed
The 11 Best Sleeper Chairs You’ll Prefer to Your Own Damn Bed
We’ve Tested Over 100 Blankets—These Are the Ones BHG Editors Swear By
We’ve Tested Over 100 Blankets—These Are the Ones BHG Editors Swear By