
1/13
Is it OK to hang the TV over the fireplace?
This article delves into a detailed debate among two home design professionals regarding the placement of a television above a fireplace mantel. Tamara Leicester, an interior designer with two decades of experience, argues against this practice, citing aesthetic, ergonomic, and practical concerns. She emphasizes the traditional role of the fireplace as the focal point of a room, intended for conversation and relaxation, rather than a TV-centric space. Leicester highlights that most fireplace mantels are too high for comfortable TV viewing, leading to neck strain. Furthermore, she finds large black TV screens visually unappealing above traditional or stone mantels, viewing them as detracting from the room's design. She also points out potential issues with visible wiring and the risk of heat damage to the television, which could void warranties. Leicester suggests alternative placements, such as placing the TV on an adjacent wall or within a media cabinet, to maintain aesthetic appeal and ergonomic comfort. She recounts designing a room divider for a client's Craftsman home to house the TV, offering a functional and beautiful solution without compromising the fireplace's integrity.
Conversely, Matt Clawson, a custom home builder and realtor, advocates for placing the TV above the fireplace, arguing that modern lifestyles have shifted the central focus of the family room from the fireplace to the television. He states that the advent of flat-screen TVs has made this placement feasible, offering a unified and centered focal point for entertainment. Clawson believes that many concerns regarding mounting are overblown due to advancements in technology, including articulating mounts like MantelMount and Dynamic Mounting, which can adjust the TV to optimal viewing angles and heights. He acknowledges the historical ideal of eye-level viewing but suggests that newer horizontal fireplace designs and adjustable mounts can mitigate this issue. Clawson also dismisses concerns about heat damage, explaining that mantels typically deflect enough heat, and manufacturer guidelines should always be followed for safe installation. He emphasizes that this placement simplifies room orientation and improves traffic flow, ultimately creating a better-looking and more functional living space.
In her rebuttal, Leicester reiterates the importance of the hearth as a symbol of family connection and argues that a TV over the fireplace promotes mindless entertainment over meaningful interaction. She criticizes adjustable mounts for exacerbating aesthetic problems and suggests that a media cabinet is a more suitable and practical solution for housing a television and its components. Clawson counters by asserting that the choice of TV placement is a matter of personal freedom and convenience. He argues that a higher TV placement can actually be more comfortable for reclining viewers and that the flat-screen revolution has made this a desirable and aesthetically pleasing option, unifying the room's focus. He concludes by stating that modern solutions allow for both a fire and a TV package, suggesting a compromise that aligns with contemporary living.
#HomeDecor #InteriorDesign #Fireplace #TVPlacement #Ergonomics #Aesthetics #HomeImprovement #SpacePlanning #DesignDebate #HomeDecor #InteriorDesign #Fireplace #TVPlacement #Ergonomics #Aesthetics #HomeImprovement #SpacePlanning #DesignDebate
0 comment in total
No comments yetYou may also like



































































